Mutation Guard Evaluation
This review lane classifies blocked mutation attempts without weakening the guard.
advisory onlyno bypassPrinciple
Mutation guard should refuse authority drift, not refuse review visibility.
Green lane
Small advisory packets, review routes, and non-mutating documentation.
Yellow lane
Interface-visible review surfaces with explicit route, pending human review, and blocked-conversion summary.
Red lane
Operational or state mutation. Requires a separate authority path, validators, negative cases, and human review.
Classification options
- correct_refusal
- over_restrictive_review_visibility_block
- needs_smaller_patch
- needs_semantic_target
- needs_validator
- needs_human_review
- red_lane_block
Review questions
- Did the refusal protect authority?
- Did it restrict review visibility?
- Was the patch too large or ambiguous?
- What smaller lawful patch should happen next?