{
  "schema_version": "musefield_next_safe_rung_decision.v0",
  "kind": "MuseFieldNextSafeRungDecisionPacket",
  "decision_id": "musefield_org.next_safe_rung_decision.v0",
  "status": "draft",
  "authority_class": "advisory",
  "jurisdiction": "musefield_org_interface_review",
  "mutates_state": false,
  "purpose": "Rank candidate next safe rungs from current visual-memory and instruction-to-proof evidence so human review can decide what should move next, why it should move, what evidence supports it, and what remains blocked.",
  "source_surfaces": [
    {
      "surface": "Visual Memory Current State Dashboard",
      "path": "apps/web/public/data/visual-memory-current-state-dashboard.v0.json",
      "public_path": "/archive/visual-memory-current-state/",
      "role": "declares current visual-memory operating state and next safe rung context"
    },
    {
      "surface": "Packet Selector Registry",
      "path": "apps/web/public/data/instruction-proof-workbench.packet-selector.v0.json",
      "public_path": "/",
      "role": "declares which packets are selectable and still review-only"
    },
    {
      "surface": "Visual Memory Comparison",
      "path": "apps/web/public/data/visual-memory-comparison.v0.json",
      "public_path": "/archive/visual-memory-comparison/",
      "role": "shows what became visible, selectable, receiptable, and still blocked"
    },
    {
      "surface": "Instruction-to-Proof Workbench",
      "path": "apps/web/public/index.html",
      "public_path": "/",
      "role": "hosts the visible review surface, packet selector, and instruction routing prototype"
    }
  ],
  "decision_question": "What should move next, and why, given the current proof surfaces and blocked conversions?",
  "decision_method": {
    "name": "review_only_candidate_ranking",
    "inputs": [
      "evidence_readiness",
      "selector_visibility",
      "public_route_readiness",
      "validator_coverage",
      "refusal_coverage",
      "human_review_clarity",
      "blocked_conversion_visibility"
    ],
    "does_not_do": [
      "choose automatically",
      "merge automatically",
      "deploy automatically",
      "mutate state",
      "replace human review"
    ]
  },
  "candidate_rungs": [
    {
      "rung_id": "wire_next_safe_rung_decision_into_selector_header_v0",
      "rank": 1,
      "title": "Wire Next Safe Rung Decision into selector and header",
      "why_now": "The dashboard is public, validated, and visible from the workbench. The next useful layer is a decision surface that turns current state into candidate movement without granting authority.",
      "evidence_paths": [
        "/data/visual-memory-current-state-dashboard.v0.json",
        "/data/instruction-proof-workbench.packet-selector.v0.json",
        "/archive/visual-memory-current-state/"
      ],
      "readiness_signals": [
        "dashboard packet exists",
        "dashboard public route exists",
        "selector/header wiring exists",
        "blocked conversions remain visible"
      ],
      "required_before_move": [
        "decision packet validation",
        "refusal fixture",
        "public decision page review",
        "human review acceptance"
      ],
      "blocked_conversions": [
        "candidate rank -> implementation",
        "decision visibility -> authority",
        "decision packet -> validator pass",
        "decision recommendation -> human approval"
      ],
      "review_state": "recommended_candidate"
    },
    {
      "rung_id": "add_cross_surface_review_receipt_v0",
      "rank": 2,
      "title": "Add cross-surface review receipt",
      "why_now": "Visual memory surfaces can now be read together, but the human review decision across dashboard, timeline, comparison, and selector is not yet receipted as one review artifact.",
      "evidence_paths": [
        "/archive/visual-memory-current-state/",
        "/archive/visual-memory-timeline/",
        "/archive/visual-memory-comparison/"
      ],
      "readiness_signals": [
        "multiple public proof surfaces exist",
        "current-state dashboard names the operational chain",
        "blocked conversions are declared in each layer"
      ],
      "required_before_move": [
        "review receipt schema",
        "validator",
        "negative refusal cases",
        "explicit human review state"
      ],
      "blocked_conversions": [
        "review receipt -> authority",
        "review receipt -> publication approval",
        "review receipt -> deployment",
        "review receipt -> state mutation"
      ],
      "review_state": "safe_next_candidate"
    },
    {
      "rung_id": "connect_decision_to_muser_world_boundary_v0",
      "rank": 3,
      "title": "Connect decision intelligence to mUser world boundary",
      "why_now": "The visual-memory system can support world-building decisions, but mUser world movement must stay behind explicit consent, profile, and human review boundaries.",
      "evidence_paths": [
        "/archive/world-creation/",
        "/data/muser-world-creation-boundary.v0.json",
        "/data/next-safe-rung-decision.v0.json"
      ],
      "readiness_signals": [
        "world creation route is linked",
        "current-state dashboard makes visual-memory state legible",
        "decision candidates can name boundaries before movement"
      ],
      "required_before_move": [
        "mUser consent boundary review",
        "profile mutation refusal cases",
        "world seed preview review",
        "human approval lane"
      ],
      "blocked_conversions": [
        "visual memory -> mUser consent",
        "decision recommendation -> profile mutation",
        "world boundary visibility -> world creation authority",
        "candidate world -> live world"
      ],
      "review_state": "held_for_boundary_review"
    }
  ],
  "decision_summary": {
    "recommended_next_rung": "wire_next_safe_rung_decision_into_selector_header_v0",
    "reason": "The safest immediate step is to make decision intelligence visible as review-only, because it completes the loop from current state to candidate movement while preserving blocked conversions.",
    "not_yet_recommended": [
      "profile mutation",
      "deployment automation",
      "economic claim assignment",
      "consent-bearing mUser world mutation"
    ]
  },
  "human_review_questions": [
    "Is the highest-ranked rung supported by current evidence paths?",
    "Does the decision explain why now without overclaiming authority?",
    "Are required-before-move conditions explicit?",
    "Are blocked conversions visible for every candidate?",
    "Should the candidate be accepted, held, refused, or escalated?"
  ],
  "blocked_conversions": [
    "ranking -> authority",
    "ranking -> validator pass",
    "ranking -> implementation",
    "recommendation -> publication approval",
    "recommendation -> consent",
    "recommendation -> identity proof",
    "recommendation -> profile mutation",
    "recommendation -> economic claim",
    "recommendation -> deployment",
    "decision visibility -> canonical truth",
    "decision packet -> human-review substitution"
  ],
  "does_not_authorize": [
    "execution",
    "state mutation",
    "profile mutation",
    "validator success claim",
    "publication approval",
    "consent claim",
    "identity proof",
    "economic claim",
    "deployment",
    "canonical truth claim",
    "human-review substitution"
  ],
  "seal_statement": "The next safe rung decision packet ranks candidate movement for human review. It does not authorize validator success, backend authority, publication approval, consent, identity proof, economic value, deployment, state mutation, canonical truth, implementation, automatic choice, or human-review substitution."
}