{
  "schema_version": "musefield_visual_memory_comparison.v0",
  "kind": "MuseFieldVisualMemoryComparisonPacket",
  "comparison_id": "musefield_org.visual_memory_comparison.v0",
  "status": "draft",
  "authority_class": "advisory",
  "jurisdiction": "musefield_org_visual_archive_reflection",
  "mutates_state": false,
  "purpose": "Compare MuseField visual memory timeline entries across archived snapshots, receipts, and selector visibility so reviewers can see what became visible, selectable, receiptable, and still blocked without converting visual memory into authority.",
  "source_surfaces": [
    {
      "surface": "Interface Progress Archive",
      "path": "apps/web/public/archive/interface-progress/index.json",
      "role": "declares the archived snapshots and their receipt boundaries"
    },
    {
      "surface": "Visual Memory Timeline",
      "path": "apps/web/public/data/visual-memory-timeline.v0.json",
      "role": "declares ordered visual memory entries and candidate next states"
    },
    {
      "surface": "Packet Selector Registry",
      "path": "apps/web/public/data/instruction-proof-workbench.packet-selector.v0.json",
      "role": "declares which visual memory packets are selectable for review"
    },
    {
      "surface": "Snapshot Reflection Receipt",
      "path": "apps/web/public/data/snapshot-reflection-receipt.v0.json",
      "role": "declares receipt boundaries for reflected current state and candidate next state"
    }
  ],
  "comparison_set": [
    {
      "entry_id": "instruction_proof_gate_v0",
      "order": 1,
      "snapshot_path": "/archive/interface-progress/snapshots/2026-06-22_instruction-proof-gate_v0.jpg",
      "receipt_path": "/archive/interface-progress/receipts/2026-06-22_instruction-proof-gate_v0.receipt.json",
      "observed_state": "MuseField had a soft static gate and early instruction-to-proof visual proof surface.",
      "became_visible": ["soft static entrance", "instruction-to-proof framing", "prototype boundary"],
      "became_selectable": [],
      "became_receiptable": ["snapshot archive receipt"],
      "still_blocked": ["validator success", "backend authority", "consent", "identity proof", "state mutation"]
    },
    {
      "entry_id": "instruction_proof_workbench_full_quality",
      "order": 2,
      "snapshot_path": "/archive/interface-progress/snapshots/musefield_instruction_to_proof_workbench_full_quality.jpg.JPG",
      "receipt_path": "/archive/interface-progress/receipts/musefield_instruction_to_proof_workbench_full_quality.receipt.json",
      "observed_state": "The workbench could show layered proof preview, backend map, packet browser, and review-only instruction routing.",
      "became_visible": ["proof preview", "backend ecosystem map", "packet browser", "human review lane"],
      "became_selectable": ["ecosystem map", "validator family map"],
      "became_receiptable": ["full-quality snapshot receipt", "snapshot reflection candidate"],
      "still_blocked": ["visual archive as canonical truth", "candidate next state as implementation", "reflection receipt as authority"]
    },
    {
      "entry_id": "current_workbench_visual_memory_v0",
      "order": 3,
      "snapshot_path": "/archive/interface-progress/snapshots/2026-06-23_current_workbench_visual_memory_v0.jpg",
      "receipt_path": "/archive/interface-progress/receipts/2026-06-23_current_workbench_visual_memory_v0.receipt.json",
      "observed_state": "MuseField can capture, receipt, register, review, merge, timeline, and select visual memory from the workbench.",
      "became_visible": ["visual memory timeline", "current workbench visual memory", "merged archive manifest entry"],
      "became_selectable": ["snapshot reflection", "reflection receipt", "visual memory timeline"],
      "became_receiptable": ["current workbench capture receipt", "timeline admission record"],
      "still_blocked": ["timeline entry as authority", "timeline visibility as canonical truth", "visual memory as consent", "candidate next state as implementation", "review state as consequence"]
    }
  ],
  "comparison_questions": [
    "What became visible across the timeline?",
    "What became selectable in the workbench?",
    "What became receiptable or archive-registered?",
    "What evidence paths support each comparison claim?",
    "Which blocked conversions remained explicit?",
    "What is the safest next build rung after review?"
  ],
  "observed_progression": {
    "visible_surfaces": [
      "soft gate",
      "instruction-to-proof workbench",
      "visual archive",
      "snapshot reflection",
      "reflection receipt",
      "visual memory timeline"
    ],
    "selector_progression": [
      "ecosystem map",
      "validator family map",
      "snapshot reflection",
      "reflection receipt",
      "visual memory timeline"
    ],
    "receipt_progression": [
      "snapshot archive receipt",
      "full-quality capture receipt",
      "snapshot reflection receipt",
      "current workbench visual memory receipt"
    ],
    "next_safe_rung": "Create a visual memory comparison page and make comparison selectable only after validator and refusal coverage pass."
  },
  "blocked_conversions": [
    "comparison entry -> authority",
    "comparison entry -> validator pass",
    "comparison entry -> consent",
    "comparison entry -> identity proof",
    "comparison entry -> profile mutation",
    "comparison entry -> economic claim",
    "comparison entry -> deployment",
    "comparison visibility -> canonical truth",
    "comparison question -> implementation",
    "review state -> consequence without governance"
  ],
  "human_review_questions": [
    "Are the compared entries supported by existing archive/timeline paths?",
    "Does each comparison claim name evidence without overstating proof?",
    "Do selectable and receiptable changes remain review-only?",
    "Which blocked conversions must stay visible on the comparison page?",
    "Should the comparison be accepted, held, refused, or escalated?"
  ],
  "does_not_authorize": [
    "execution",
    "state mutation",
    "profile mutation",
    "validator success claim",
    "publication approval",
    "consent claim",
    "identity proof",
    "economic claim",
    "deployment",
    "human-review substitution"
  ],
  "seal_statement": "The visual memory comparison packet compares archived visual memory entries for review. It does not authorize validator success, publication approval, consent, identity proof, economic value, deployment, state mutation, canonical truth, implementation, or human-review substitution."
}